How to play

It is the end of a year somewhere between 2005 and 2020. You don’t know which. Read the wire and each asset’s return “last year” to work out the era.

How to Play Erstwhile Unlimited

Erstwhile Unlimited is a free stock market history game. You land at the end of an unnamed year between 2005 and 2020, read the clues to work out when you are, and spread $10,000 across a handful of real stocks and assets. Five years of actual market returns then play out, and you win if your portfolio finishes ahead of an S&P 500 fund over the same stretch.

The rules, step by step

Your $10,000 comes as ten chips worth $1,000 each. A round offers seven places to put them: four stocks, two other assets and cash. You can stack up to four chips on any one option, and you have to place all ten before you can lock in.

After you lock in, two years pass. You see what your money is worth and a new headline arrives. Now you choose: Hold keeps every position exactly as it is, while Rebalance sells everything and lets you place ten new chips, each worth a tenth of what you have now. Two more years pass and you get the same choice one last time. Then the fifth year plays out and the real dates appear.

Reading the clues

The year is hidden, so the game gives you three kinds of evidence. The wire shows a real news headline from that year. Each card lists the asset's return for the year that just ended, marked green when it rose and red when it fell. A one-line description says what each company does.

Stocks are drawn from a pool of 86 well-known companies. The other two slots come from 26 assets, among them gold, silver, crude oil, copper, wheat, coffee and long-dated US Treasuries. Cash earns nothing, but it can never lose value.

How your result is judged

The finish screen shows your final balance, what an S&P 500 fund made over the same five years, and a verdict that ranges from Ran aground up to Struck gold. It also compares you with a crowd of simulated players and with a large random sample of every legal plan, and it reveals the best possible play with perfect hindsight. A ledger and a short backstory show how each asset moved and why. The menu keeps your record: rounds played, how often you beat the market, and your current and best streaks.

Strategy tips for beating the S&P 500

Date the round before you place a chip. A headline about a bank collapse or a bailout tells you something very different from one about a new phone launch, and the right era changes everything about which assets are likely to run.

Use last year's returns as a clue, not a forecast. A huge one-year jump can mean a company is early in a long climb, or that a commodity has already peaked. Think about what came next.

Remember the four-chip limit. You cannot go all in on one stock, so your best idea gets at most 40% and the rest needs a home. Cash is a fair place for spare chips when you expect a crash, since a 0% return beats a falling index.

Holding lets winners keep compounding, while rebalancing resets every position to an equal split of your new total. If the new headline changes your read of the era, that is usually the moment to rebalance.

Why play on Everythingle

Erstwhile Unlimited is free, needs no account or sign-up, and has no daily limit. It runs in any browser on a phone or a computer, and a round in progress is saved in your browser if you step away. Everythingle is a collection of free games across many categories, from word and geography puzzles to music, math, perception, pop culture and two-player games.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Erstwhile Unlimited based on real market data?

Yes. Stock, metal and S&P 500 figures are year-end closes adjusted for splits and dividends, and commodity prices are December averages of world prices. The headlines on the wire are real news headlines from the year in question.

What years can a round cover?

Every round takes place between 2005 and 2020. You start at the end of a hidden year and invest through the next five, and the actual dates are revealed when the round ends.

How do you win a round of Erstwhile?

You win when your final balance beats what an S&P 500 fund would have made over the same five years. Losing less than the market in a bad stretch still counts as a win.

What does rebalancing do in Erstwhile?

Rebalancing sells all of your positions and gives you ten new chips, each worth one tenth of your current total, to place again under the same four-chip limit. Choosing Hold leaves your positions untouched.

Is there a limit on how many rounds I can play?

No. Erstwhile Unlimited has no daily puzzle, so you can start a new round from the menu or with the Play again button whenever you finish.

If you enjoy this investing history puzzle, try PricePoint to guess what things cost, Fermi Unlimited for estimation questions, Scale of Things for comparing sizes, or Dartle Unlimited for trivia darts. You can see every math game together, or head back for more free games on Everythingle.